Scrutiny is even more important in light of the new powers that devolution brings. Effective scrutiny acts as a “critical friend” to decision-makers at the HSCCA. It supports better decision-making by reviewing policies, examining performance, and making constructive recommendations.
In practice, this means the Overview and Scrutiny Committee looks at decisions, plans and outcomes. By doing this, scrutiny helps drive improvement, increase transparency, and strengthen accountability.
The HSCCA Overview and Scrutiny Committee enables councillors to represent their communities by questioning and challenging the Board and, in future, the HSCCA Mayor. It focuses on the strategic issues that matter most to residents and aims to influence decisions in the public interest.
The Committee is made up of ten councillors, with two representatives from each of the constituent councils except Hampshire County Council who will nominate four representatives. In addition, at least two co-opted members will be appointed, whilst ensuring that the majority of members of the Overview & Scrutiny Committee are members of the constituent councils. Membership reflects, as far as possible, the overall political balance across those councils. There will also be substitute members nominated who can step in when needed to ensure the Committee continues to operate effectively.
The membership was confirmed at the meeting on 28 September 2026.
Councillor Steve Andrews
Councillor Chrissie Bainbridge
Councillor Antonia Cox
Councillor Chris Dorn
Councillor Lorna Fielker
Councillor Paul Kenny
Councillor Reuben Loake
Councillor Colin Towell
Councillor James Whelan
Councillor Matthew Winnington
The following substitutes were confirmed on 28 September 2026:
Councillor Stuart Bailey
Councillor Paul Carter
Councillor Gordon Cooper
Councillor Kate Dorrington
Councillor Yvonne Frampton
Councillor Juliet Henderson
Councillor Dan Poole
Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson CBE
Councillor Paul Williams
Venue: Executive Room – Civic Offices, Portsmouth City Council. Location details
Overview & Scrutiny Committee Agenda – 12.10.26
Venue: County Hall, Isle of Wight Council. Location details
Venue: Executive Room – Civic Offices, Portsmouth City Council. Location details
Venue: Asburton Hall – The Castle, Winchester, Hampshire County Council. Location details